
21) “The Watcher by the Threshold” by John Buchan
Plot:
Our hero, Henry, a lawyer, is enjoying some vacation time out shooting (ICK, but yeah) at a friend’s estate when he receives a letter from his cousin, Sibyl, asking him to visit her and her husband in Scotland. She adds a postscript: “For Heaven’s sake, come and see us. Bob is ill, and I am crazy. Don’t bother about bringing doctors. It is not their business.”
As much as he doesn’t want to leave the comforts of the present place, he sees how desperate his cousin is and goes to see them. It is a miserable drive. Henry describes the landscape as dreary and full of “faded gentility.”
To his surprise, he finds his cousin’s husband as cheerful as ever. He looks healthy. Sibyl, on the other hand, has changed. She is pale, her pretty eyes are now mournful, and, in place of her “delightful shyness,” are “the self-confidence and composure of pain.”
Is it perhaps Sibyl who is ill, and not Bob?
At dinner, Bob seems to be unable to recall the recent past. A bust of the Byzantine Emperor Justinian is both a prominent decoration and something of a forbidden topic. Something panics Bob, and Sibyl comforts him, stroking his hair “as one would stroke a frightened horse.”
A few minutes later, Bob picks up the conversation as if nothing happened. Has Sibyl calmed him, or has he forgotten whatever it was that frightened him?
Later, when Bob and Henry withdraw to smoke cigars, Bob refuses to smoke. Sibyl has asked Henry to find out what is bothering Bob; her husband won’t tell her.
Henry tries some tactful inquiry. After some hemming and hawing, Bob says his concern involves, “The devil.”
Thoughts:
This novelette is atmospheric and sad. As much as Henry wishes nothing were wrong with Bob, there is clearly something going on. He refers to the other man as “a commonplace man, with fair talents, a mediocre culture, honest instincts, and the beliefs and incredulities of his class. … He had a kind of dull, bourgeois rationalism, which used to find reasons for all things in heaven and earth.”
Not the kind of person Henry would expect to be subject to hallucinations.
In discussing Justinian at the uncomfortable (to say the least) dinner, Bob says he recalls a story about Justinian selling his soul to the devil for laws. Sibyl tries to tell him to change the subject. A less demure woman would have kicked his shin black and blue.
Henry is concerned about his cousin as well as her husband, but he really wants to be gone.
The ending of the story I read proved unsatisfying. Apparently, it is sometimes anthologized as a fragment with an unsatisfying ending.
There is a reason for that. Apparently, the version I read is truncated. A fuller version, available at the Gutenberg Project (see below), wanders a bit but at least leaves our hero looking less like a jerk.
An unabridged version of the story can be read here:
An unabridged version of the story can be listened to here: (1:47:41)
Bio: John Buchan (1875-1940) was a British statesman, writer, and publisher, best known for his adventure stories. Among his best-known books is Thirty-Nine Steps (1915), which was adapted into the movie of the same name, directed by Alfred Hitchcock. He also wrote a biography, Sir Walter Scott (1932). In 1935, he was appointed governor-general of Canada.
Title: “The Watcher by the Threshold”
Author: John Buchan (1875-1940)
First published: The Watcher by the Threshold and Other Stories, 1902
Length: novelette









