Our last pizza and bad movie night of the year! We watched the flick with a black cat snoozing on the couch on his bed between us—after we finished the pizza. Unfortunately, the little guy can’t be trusted around pizza.
The Plot:
Elderly, infirm Henrietta Winslow (Cecilia Loftus) has called her family together to let them know the contents of her will. The news that the family has come together has also drawn a realtor, A. Gilmore Smith (Broderick Crawford), an acquaintance of Mrs. Winslow’s granddaughter Elaine Winslow (Anne Gwynne), and an antiques dealer, Mr. Penny (Hugh Herbert).
The groundskeeper (Bela Lugosi) tells them to leave their car outside the grounds. Since a car killed one of her (many) cats, Mrs. Winslow doesn’t allow cars on the grounds. The elderly woman’s caretaker, Abigail Doone (Gale Sondergaard), refuses to let Mr. Smith and Mr. Penny into the house, so they go around to a back entrance.
Mr. Smith is allergic to Mrs. Winslow’s small herd of cats and sneezes often. Mr. Penny chuckles to himself a lot, making high-pitched “hoo-hoo” sounds. Mr. Smith’s sneezing is far less annoying.
Mr. Smtih’s sneezing gives them away. They are soon ushered into the room where Mrs. Winslow hasn’t finished reading her will. She sits in her wheelchair with a Siamese kitten in her lap who plays with the papers she’s holding. The heirs seem content with their expected windfalls, except for Mrs. Winslow’s son-in-law, Montague Hartley (Basil Rathbone), who receives a mere $10,000. As it turns out, he has some heavy debts.
Later, Mrs. Winslow takes an unfortunate cat to the crematorium on the grounds. Many urns line the shelves. A statue of a black cat moves on its base, revealing the entrance to a secret passageway. Mrs. Winslow knows the person who comes but is surprised. She then screams in terror.
Her family finds her dead, stabbed with a knitting needle. Poor Grandma must have fallen and hurt herself. How tragic! How unlike murder!
Thoughts:
While Edgar Allen Poe is mentioned in the credits, this movie bears little resemblance to his short story of the same name. The two share creepiness—Mrs. Winslow’s cat crematorium and shrine, where she plans for her earthly remains to be entombed—are just one example. On the other hand, given her greedy family, I can understand why she prefers the company of her cats.
When it becomes apparent that Mrs. Winslow’s death was no accident (ya think?), Mr. Smith tries to determine who is responsible. Contacting the authorities is out of the question. Someone has cut the phone wires, and the bridge to town has washed away in the storm.
Many stock threats appear in the movie: a hand reaches out from behind a drape and empties something into Mrs. Winslow’s milk. Mr. Smith, on the hunt for the will, receives a stunning punch in the face from behind a drape. Sinister-looking groundskeeper Eduardo hangs around by windows, listening to conversations no one means him to hear.
Mr. Smith decides to find out who killed Mrs. Winslow. Unfortunately for him, he goes off half-cocked, annoying the family and making himself look like a fool in front of the girl he’s trying to impress, Elaine.
In the meantime, Mr. Penny is evaluating the various furnishings, “antiquing” them by damaging and destroying them. He also stumbles across a series of secret passages, not realizing what they are, and ends up in the bedroom of the sourpuss maid, Abigail. He finds her lying in a footlocker with a black cat…
Abigail recovers.
Much of the movie reminded me of an even more ancient flick, The Old Dark House.
In true murder mystery fashion, nearly everyone involved is not what the viewer expects. I did not guess the bad’un. While I liked it, I have to admit that many things are unlikely, and silly, and might try the patience of the average viewer. It can work if you know what you’re getting into and don’t take it too seriously.
The movie can be watched here.
Happy 2024 to all.
Title: The Black Cat (1941)
Directed by
Albert S. Rogell
Writing Credits
Robert Lees…(screenplay) and
Frederic I. Rinaldo…(screenplay) (as Fred Rinaldo) and
Eric Taylor…(screenplay) and
Robert Neville…(screenplay)
Edgar Allan Poe…(suggested by story by)
Cast (in credits order)
Basil Rathbone…Montague Hartley
Hugh Herbert…Mr. Penny
Broderick Crawford…A. Gilmore Smith
Bela Lugosi…Eduardo Vidos
Anne Gwynne…Elaine Winslow
Released: 1941
Length: 1 hour, 10 minutes








